Kyle Scollin

Name Goes Here

Company: Scollin Designs
Website: www.scollindesigns.com

About Me: I am a recent college graduate who studied graphic design. I'm excited about this field and always want to learn more.

User's Concepts

Users Last 25 Reviews

  • Poster - Happy Birthday IV

    1 Vote
    The variation on the dots

    Posted on Mar 28, 2010 at 3:06 PM

    I think you've made a wonderful design here. Its really great and simplistic and you even did a good job with the colors. I think that I would try to even vary the dot sizes bit more. You have so many that are the same size as they go out to the branches, and you could even make bigger dots in the trunk area. Also I don't know if the dark background is part of the card or not, but if it is, I don't know if its necessary. But really a great design. Nice job.

    • Metin Ucar
      Metin Ucar commented:
      Posted: on Apr 03, 2010 at 8:04 AM

      hi there Kyle,

      first of all, thanks for the feedback. I really appreciate it. In the initial design, I used various dot sizes (approximately up to 10 different sizes). but it was kinda time consuming and hard to keep track of what I was doing. So, I scrapped that version. The one you see now is the 2nd version and here I decided to use only 4 different dot sizes. While forming the tree shape with these dots, it seemed a good decision because it saved me a lot of time. However, after reading your feedbacks, I realised my decision of using only 4 different dot sizes was not a good decision, at least not as good as I thought before. So, I see and agree with your point. In similar prospective projects, I'll keep your feedback in mind. Thanks.

  • Burdii Logo

    1 Vote
    The i's

    Posted on Mar 28, 2010 at 3:01 PM

    So overall I really love your logo (actually the first one I think is best). Its simple and cute. I think the problem is what everyone else has said: the bird looks kind of sad or confused and small and cute, not really portraying the idea of unique fashion. Also I don't know why you've given a different color treatment to the two letter i's. They don't need to stand out, or if they are standing out for a reason, I don't understand it. So it just depends what you want for the client. Again, I think you have a great logo, it just may not be the best for unusual fashion.

  • Wedding website

    0 Votes
    Refinement

    Posted on Dec 30, 2009 at 11:31 PM

    You're going in the right direction. There's a few things that look like they need cleaning up. The blending of the guy's hair, there is a lot of white pieces. The gradient behind the words s too noticeable, and I feel like the green button bar is not too attractive. Perhaps toning back that green a bit would help. I really like the embellishments on the small photos, and the main gray background is really nice. Keep it up.

    • Andy E
      Andy E commented:
      Posted: on Dec 31, 2009 at 9:00 AM

      Thanks for the feedback, Kyle. The photo is temporary - the bride and groom haven't supplied me with their photos yet. I'm not sure what you mean by "the gradient behind the words is too noticeable". Could you please explain?

      I've toned down the border around the boxes, replaced the swirl at the top with something nicer, and removed the glow behind the title text. I'll submit a revised concept soon.

  • My Logo

    0 Votes
    The Letter F

    Posted on Dec 08, 2009 at 12:07 PM

    Are the e and the f two different fonts? I feel like they are clashing a bit. I think it would work better as 1 font. Though it does look pretty classy as is. I would still play around with the two letters a bit more to see if a more scripty font might flow better.

    • Earl Fernandes
      Earl Fernandes commented:
      Posted: on Dec 08, 2009 at 1:07 PM

      Thanks, Yeah the E and F are 2 different fonts> Should I just play aorund with the kerning to make it more readable or change the font for earl fernandes

    • Kyle Scollin
      Kyle Scollin commented:
      Posted: on Dec 08, 2009 at 1:21 PM

      I think I would just mess with the 2 letters. The E and the F. Try changing them into a script font or make them both the same font and see how they flow.

    • MB Hayes
      MB Hayes commented:
      Posted: on Dec 08, 2009 at 2:10 PM

      Hey... if either of you guys are interested I just ran into this post in my google reader (similar styles to yours in there as well) ...

      http://webdesignledger.com/inspiration/a-showcase-of-clever-negative-space-in-logo-design

  • Sleek Black Portfolio

    0 Votes
    the wording

    Posted on Dec 07, 2009 at 8:16 PM

    This is looking really nice. Lots of white space to allow the eyes some space to move around. I feel like since the words will be the first thing a visitor will read, it might need some rewording. The word "things" seems kind of vague and perhaps unnecessary. You could just say "with a knack for design." Also the next sentence starts with the word "Combined" and I'm not sure what that refers to. Perhaps its supposed to all be one sentence "I'm a web guy with a knack for design, combined with ..."

    I dig the wood texture. As my friend says "Everything looks better on a wood background" haha.

    • Codedude
      Codedude commented:
      Posted: on Dec 08, 2009 at 10:16 AM

      I changed it slightly as you advised...

  • Inspire Logo

    0 Votes
    hmm..

    Posted on Dec 07, 2009 at 8:10 PM

    I definitely preferred your BrightSpark logos. I guess I don't really understand the connection of the paper airplanes with getting design inspiration. Also the paper airplanes either seem to be not moving or actually crashing haha.

  • Solid Rock WebDesign

    1 Vote
    The Star

    Posted on Dec 07, 2009 at 1:17 PM

    It seems like a lot of people are using grunge in the design of their websites for God. I don't think I really felt hawaiian from this at all. I think that big red star feels out of place and attracting a lot of attention. I think your main content area though looks pretty nice. I like the idea of having a gallery or video right there. I'm 22 and pictures and videos online are very attractive. I'm not sure if blogs are the next best thing to put. Maybe having an "Upcoming events" or "get involved" section or something might get people more active.

    • Joao Campos
      Joao Campos commented:
      Posted: on Dec 08, 2009 at 10:44 AM

      I know it's kind of odd, I myself didn't want to design a church website in such a "messy" and grungy way, but that was the main request from the client so I had to follow. In fact, there were some palm trees popping in the header background before and for my mistake, they were gone when I applied the family picture. That was already fixed.

      I totally agree with you regarding the red start. That was my idea actually, they never asked for anything like that. I just put that in there after researching the web for church's websites and I found out that it was a very common element. But most of them are just like that, they don't self-explain themselves and I created that more because it would look cool than for usability reasons (my mistake again!). For now, I'm thinking of replacing that star with some sort of player where users can listen to the sermons (a quick link to the podcast section).

      Thanks!

  • BrightSpark Logo

    0 Votes
    Variation 2

    Posted on Dec 07, 2009 at 3:49 AM

    I like the font and colors are working well. I feel like the spark above the word bright, reminds me too much of a sun. I like variation 1 the best because it has a strong concept and works well. I think the white should have a bit more depth to it though, it feels a bit too flat, compared to the gradient on the rest of the logo.

  • My Branding

    1 Vote
    The Smoke

    Posted on Dec 07, 2009 at 3:35 AM

    I think its basically been said, but watch some of the kerning, and also when designing logos you have to think about where it will be used. If its just on a website then using the graphic of smoke works alright. But as soon as it goes into print the smoke is going to die. Also if its viewed as a small icon (perhaps a favicon) then the smoke won't view very well. Designing logos in black and white is how I learned to do it, though many now use all sorts of gradients and stuff so who knows.

  • Business Card for Life Coach

    0 Votes
    Overall Concept

    Posted on Dec 07, 2009 at 3:30 AM

    I feel that this design is a bit too green. The colors are green, and photos of nature are used. I think that especially with words like "resources" the first thought isn't about a life coach. Also in the first card the silhouette of the lady seems like she's really small in the grass, not necessarily "tapping into her strength" But of these, I think the third one is the most professional looking.

  • Serivaahtera web site, v. 2.5

    0 Votes
    think about the actual content

    Posted on Dec 07, 2009 at 3:24 AM

    Both sites really look nice and well designed. I actually prefer how you've given the images a larger size in the second one, but I like the use of content in the top area of the first one. I think you need to figure out if you can actually fill all of that text with real text because right now it looks great, but when the real text comes in, it might mess up the layout.