-
The first one is better. It conveys a mood and a kind of nostalgia and hominess, whether lodge, camp, country club, or whatever. That would look good in print, web, or other media. Very versatile. The others, with subtle off-white type behind, doesn't read well on screen. Thanks, great submission.

Thanks for your feedback. I was partial to the first one also. However the Client has already chosen the second one.