-
The only one here that comes anywhere close is the second. It uses far nicer fonts then the first one, and the platter design with the logo makes it obvious who the advert is appealing to.
However, I would try and get the bpm logo to sit directly in the middle of the platter, as it would if it was a real vinyl platter.
I think you need to make a way for the advert to look more friendly, and less corporate. I'm not sure how you would achieve this.
But the second is the way to go, it's attractive.
The scores I have given are based on the first and third. For the second I'd give:
- 4
- 3
- 2
- 4

Thanks Michael, that's really helpful.