-
I know you are trying to keep with the current lcb design while still making it fresh, but I would suggest incorporating a few more elements. They have a very simple navigation located at the top right of the site on the current page. I would suggest keeping this consistent. This will limit user frustration.
Would love to know why your target is church members, but this design is clearly targeted at new visitors. I would think a member would be looking for information on upcoming events, current message series, etc. I work for LiquidChurch.com and I know it is always a hard balance between new visitors and current members.

Thanks for the review Matt, some good feedback to chew on.