A Review of Concept Feedback V3 by Nate Hamilton

First let me mention how this is going to be a very difficult task to redesign concept feedback and please everyone at first. We use this site so much that our judgment is a little clouded because we are use to the current design.

What I like about the new design:

1. I love the featured member area is set up now, showing all of the work instead of just the one project.
2. Like the ability to see all of the unreviewed. Hopefully this will be specific to me, showing me all the things I have not reviewed.
3. You hit the spot with the new concept detail page. The way the review's are set up is amazingly clear and straight forward. I am so excited about the previous version spot that allow me to quickly view them (THANK YOU!). I also like the set up of the rating system right by your name.
4. Genius idea to add the follow this concept. Please let it email me when somebody has made another review.

Overall I like where you are headed with this design but think there are a few things that could be improved:

1. Why are there different roll over states for the premium concepts then the best today. I would have to see this is action but it doesn't seem to make complete sense.
2. In general the main page feels a bit cluttered and busy. Anything you can do to simplify things would be appreciated.
3. I like what you have done with the featured member section but putting at the bottom feels like it is a bit less of a feature then before.
4. I miss the ability to not like something and eventually vote it off. It felt like we had a little bit of power.

I think I covered most of the things I wanted to say. Like I said, overall I like where you are headed with this and ultimately trust your judgment on where this ship (concept feedback) needs to go. A few last things that I hope you don't forget in the next iteration of CF:

1. Ability to format email and comments as well as add attachments in them both.
2. The ability to see who is following you.
3. The ability to collapse comments that you don't want to see so you can focus on the ones you do want to see.
4. Let us follow certain people and send us email when that person post a new concept.
5. IPHONE APP!!!! I know it's easier said then done but this would be a great iphone app and would increase your viewership.

I'm sure I'm forgetting a few things, let me know if you have any questions. Great work so far, look forward to seeing it in action!