Noel TockPremium Concept

Rare Disease Charity (Draft)

By Noel Tock

   on Nov 27, 2010
13 Reviews2 Votes1 Favorite450 Views

Concept Reviews

  • Lil Monster

    Lil Monster

    Rank: 3 Superior

    490

    • Design: 1
    • Purpose: 2
    • Originality: 1
    • Engagement: 2
    2 Votes
    This review has been awarded.
    Glorified Sponsors Needs To Go

    Posted on Nov 27, 2010 at 11:46 AM

    You're off to a good start. I know how difficult it can be working with a client that doesn't allow you creative freedom. Def. a pain in the hiney.

    But sometimes, with constraints, it can help focus our creativity better. One such thing is playing with typography. With CSS3, it's awesome that we have the opportunity to play with as many fonts as possible.

    First off, I abhor the sponsors section, drives me nuts when someone thinks it matters but I'm sure the client wants it there. (take it out when it's launched ;d)

    I notice you don't really have a call to action like donate now (Yes, I see the button at the top, but have more and make it the first element of the navigation.)

    So, I came up with a slight alternative for ya. The heading is Aller from FontSquirrel.

    Psst. I know there's a lot of padding in between columns but maybe make it 3 columns.

    Another idea is having a really big background image and have the containers with text be white with rounded corners to give a more emotional connection to the user. The featured images to actually be news items so people know when something's new.

    Hope this helps!

    • 804ba49b-de66-4b25-a818-649ed825cc01.jpg
    • Luke Marohn
      Luke Marohn commented:
      Posted: on Nov 28, 2010 at 8:33 PM

      awesome review you lil' monster! ;)

    • Noel Tock
      Noel Tock commented:
      Posted: on Dec 02, 2010 at 12:02 PM

      Thanks for the review "Lil Monster"! Lot of good comments, some feedback:

      • I'll be going with the Facit font as it's a typekit (I actually originally had Aller in there though ;) )
      • Client doesn't want a Slideshow so that's out of the question

      Cheers

      Noel

    • Lil Monster
      Lil Monster commented:
      Posted: on Dec 02, 2010 at 12:17 PM

      Oh right. i originally had a sentence, but it wanted to be a solo. So here it is -fetches spotlight and shines on the following sentence- I would like to see this design using your all-out textured style.

    • Noel Tock
      Noel Tock commented:
      Posted: on Dec 02, 2010 at 12:35 PM

      I also want to see my all-out textured style, trust me :)

  • Michael Rawlins

    Michael Rawlins

    Rank: 1 Elite

    CF Verified professional

    18059

    • Design: 5
    • Purpose: 5
    • Originality: 3
    • Engagement: 4
    2 Votes
    This review has been awarded.
    Slight Change to Content Area on Homepage

    Posted on Nov 27, 2010 at 5:48 PM

    Noel,

    Dramatic improvement over the current design.

    What's Strongest:

    • Emotional photo on the banner - is extremely persuasive and frames the type of site at a glance. It satisfies superficial interests from a psychological standpoint versus someone interested in elaborate details.
    • Fat Footer area - creates a great area for placing ancillary information.
    • Level 2 page is very strong...

    What Needs Additional Work:

    • The two columns could benefit from more rigorous design. Try a list module approach (see mock-up)
    • Rework Light Blue Sub-titles
    • Rework the Sponsorship logos in that section
    • mockup_2.png

    Notes Added to Images   View

    • Front Page
      • 1Redesign 2nd Column

      • 2This blue doesn't really work well

        Strive for more contrast

    • Noel Tock
      Noel Tock commented:
      Posted: on Dec 02, 2010 at 12:03 PM

      Thank you Michael!

      Lot of great comments there and thanks for the mockup, gave me some ideas :)

      Cheers

      Noel

  • Aaran Casey

    Aaran Casey

    Rank: 1 Elite

    22778

    • Design: 4
    • Purpose: 4
    • Originality: 3
    • Engagement: 4
    2 Votes
    This review has been awarded.
    Noel...

    Posted on Nov 28, 2010 at 12:53 PM

    Looks like you have been hard at work? This is nicely done however there are a few tweaks that need to be addressed, I'll use notes.

    So overall, as always a very nicely designed site, I would just make a few tweaks and Voila!

    Good Luck!

    Notes Added to Images   View

    • Front Page
      • 1Alignment

        This really should be aligned with the rest

      • 2I don't think

        this explanation is needed

      • 3Heading font

        Maybe it's just because it's bold, but looks to be a different font. IMHO, I think it would look better not bolded

      • 4Lines

        These are to thick, make them 1 pixel

      • 5Sponsors

        It's a good idea, but maybe look at making them grey until you rollover them

      • 6Wasted space

        tsk tsk

      • 7Alignment

        this heading is not in line with content either above or below

      • 81 pixel out

      • 9This isn't aligned

        with anything

      • 10put the header image here

        to match with the other images, and even it out a little, also reduce some of that wasted space

      • 11Icon

        looks out of place, doesn't really suit this style

    Notes Added to Images   View

    • Sub Page
      • 1Don't like this

        at all!

      • 2Title is

        Sentence case, and then Sub Header 2 and 3 below are all caps, why?

      • 3wasted space

        I know it's only a mock up, but this looks odd

    • Noel Tock
      Noel Tock commented:
      Posted: on Dec 02, 2010 at 12:28 PM

      Hi Aaran,

      Thanks a lot for the comments and annotations (a lot of the small margin issues, white space, etc. were due to it being a draft and me working with the same height despite content, till finalized). Good comments re font and other things, helped out!

      Cheers

      Noel

  • Joel Acevedo

    Joel Acevedo

    Rank: 1 Elite

    1574

    • Design: 3
    • Purpose: 3
    • Originality: 3
    • Engagement: 3
    2 Votes
    This review has been awarded.
    COLOR COMBO

    Posted on Nov 30, 2010 at 8:57 PM

    Hello!

    I have mix feelings about this design. My head is spinning and my mind doesn't settle: one side say nice draft... the other side say NOT SO FAST, MISTER!

    One think that bothers me is the color combo. I love white. I love gray. I love the light blue. But they make the site looks too sad! At least give the site some RAY OF LIGHT!

    May I suggest using a darker gray or black for header, slideshow/big image, footer. Get rid of gradient on footer. Then use blue to highlight some features... and add another color (maybe a dark red) to headers, etc.

    Or just go fully dark. I think message will stand out more.

    I like the menu except the DONATE button. Looks out of place. Why don't you do this: let us see the whole girl's face... position her to the left. Then instead of a horizontal block, make the block vertical on the right. Put your main message and below the message (same block) put your DONATE button. Make it BIGGER!!! After all, that's the purpose of the site... to get donations.

    Separate the panels/blocks a little bit.

    Overview is ok... but that header looks bad. Use another font. Consider using another color when background is white. That blue looks good on black but on white it looks weak.

    News are ok... but header looks bad. View all is a link... so make it look like a link. Images can go, in my opinion. If you still need images there, consider making them smaller. Another suggestion is to change the lighter background, maybe to a light blue.

    You should move sponsors from that column and display a full block. So Overview and News will be columns, and under these cols you'll have the Sponsors.

    Footer is ok... but Important Links look out of palce with the other two cols. Oh, and get rid of gradient.

    As for the subpage, if you want to keep the image then you can make it smaller... maybe full width but just 80px high. Or make it a square and float it to the right inside the Page or Post.

    I honestly don't like the Navigation there. In fact, I don't like the navigation at all. If you just want to have a sidebar, then keep it to the right. After all that's where you have the NEWS on the Homepage. Be consistent! Oh and if it is a sidebar, then use it more wisely. Don't just put navigation links. And the blue bar... yikes! Doesn't match with rest of design.

    But not bad for a draft. Keep up the good work.

    • orphanbiotec_mydraft.png
    • Joel Acevedo
      Joel Acevedo commented:
      Posted: on Nov 30, 2010 at 10:38 PM

      Sorry I didn't use your girl's pic! I wanted a full face pic and yours is cutted by block... so I had to use this one instead. but you get the point!

    • Noel Tock
      Noel Tock commented:
      Posted: on Dec 02, 2010 at 1:25 PM

      Hi Joel,

      Excellent and practical comments, and I really like the header on the re-work you did.

      Thanks a ton!

      Cheers

      Noel

    • Joel Acevedo
      Joel Acevedo commented:
      Posted: on Dec 02, 2010 at 5:03 PM

      Hey, Noel... glad I was able to help. After all, that's what we all are here for! Keep up with the good work!

  • Ian Franklin

    Ian Franklin

    Rank: 1 Elite

    CF Verified professional

    612

    • Design: 4
    • Purpose: 5
    • Originality: 3
    • Engagement: 4
    2 Votes
    This review has been awarded.
    The scary picture

    Posted on Nov 29, 2010 at 4:45 AM

    Overall I like it; the blue and black colour scheme gives a powerful presentation with a medical overtone.

    I have no problem with Wordpress. Many professional designers malign it but it can do more than blogging and gives an easy to use CMS interface.

    See my comments on the annotations.

    Notes Added to Images   View

    • Front Page
      • 1Needs to be a white text box

        Make teh text box white so people know where they can type and that they can type. At the moment the box is barely visible.

      • 2very strong logo

        I like the logo it is very powerful, I think it is the blue and black combination. Makes it look clean and medical

      • 3Home page

        Maybe I am old fashioned but I like a home page link. So many people expect and it is not intuitive to all that sometimes clicking the logo does the same as a home link.

      • 4Scary picture

        I agree that you need an emotive picture but for me this might be too emotive and will turn people away. To me the girl is saying "If you do not donate I will die and then my restless soul will come and haunt your family for all eternity". Its too horror film. Think of a colour photo rather than black and white - at the moment its a bit "film noir".

      • 5Wrong place

        All the other items here are navigation whereas this is a call to action. It looks as if you are asking for money before people have had chance to read the site and what the charity does. Either change this to a navigation item "How to donate" or move the donate button into the top header by the search option.

      • 6I like thick lines

        I like the thick lines; I think that the usability of sites is greatly increased by showing clear boudaries between headings, different types of content, and tasks\calls to action.

      • 7What a wste of space

        If you must have sponsors then greatly reduce the size to at least a quarter of what ir current is. My suggestion is put in the footer if possible

      • 8Not needed here

        Just make meet the team a sub-page of About Us. I think that this space could be better used or you could put the sponsors here.

      • 9I like news here

        I think that using the right bar for News works well on the home page. Gets people seeing immediately what the charity has been doing.

      • 10Who are they for?

        OK you have forums but who are they for: Spnsors? People with rare diseases to get help? People who donate? For people who donate to correspond with sufferers? Medical staff to get advice when dealing with rare diseases? I think you need something upfront about what the forums are about, their purpose.

    Notes Added to Images   View

    • Sub Page
      • 1Context sensitive?

        I am assuming that this will be a context sensitive bar for the content of this section? If so great.

      • 2Have on home page too? Make smaller.

        I think that this should also be on the home page either above or below the news section in the right bar. However make it smaller, about half the size it currently is. The problem with big donation buttons and donate now messages is that people can be put off as they feel they are being mugged\robbed. Smaller is more subtle and perhaps persuasive. Perhaps do an A\B test through Google Optimiser, which is free. There is probably by now a Google Optimiser plug in for Wordpress.

      • 3Why change in heading style?

        On the home page the heading was in black text with a thick grey separator line underneath. I suggest you are consistent with the headingstyle chosen for all pages.

    • Noel Tock
      Noel Tock commented:
      Posted: on Dec 02, 2010 at 1:06 PM

      Thank you Ian, some really great comments in there. I've already added a few of the items!

      Cheers

      Noel

  • Alex Colina

    Alex Colina

    Rank: 1 Elite

    7088

    • Design: 4
    • Purpose: 2
    • Originality: 1
    • Engagement: 2
    2 Votes
    This review has been awarded.
    Address confusing name

    Posted on Nov 29, 2010 at 5:42 PM

    I like the clean intent of the design and encourage you to stay with that. You need to keep it very very simple. Here is how I see the problem. This is a site that will be turned over to non-designers to maintain using a fairly permissive CMS with very little or no checks on picture sizes, fonts and a million other things that can make the site look like a disaster in a hurry. So your design needs to take this into account.

    1. don't rely on the big emotive picture. The design needs to work no matter what they put in there.
    2. do not do images in every heading. Same problem as #1 only that it starts out difficult. What is a good picture for forums? You could introduce a layout for secondary pages where a picture at the text level is optional
      1. Use more blue
      2. DO NOT TAKE OUT THE SPONSORS!!!!! the sponsors are important to...themselves. They pay the bills. instead solve the problem, make them all gray with a color hover lined up into neat boxes at the bottom. in fact you could go in the other direction and feature on the top one sponsor a month explaining why they support this cause. it will make the home page more dynamic and give sponsors more notoriety.
      3. if this is going to be a blog format "news" needs to be more important that the static text of "overview"
      4. If I may say so again. Keep it clean and uncluttered as you have it now

    A little off topic:

    Address the confusing name OrphanBiotech

    My first impression when I saw this was that is was about orphans! and the girl picture only reinforced that. Somehow you need to convey "underfunded" or "non-funded" biotech research. A pic of an actual beneficiary with a caption: Hi I am Johnny I have a disease that only 30 other people in the world have. I am counting on one person (you) to find a cure.

    • Noel Tock
      Noel Tock commented:
      Posted: on Dec 02, 2010 at 1:13 PM

      Thanks Alex! Some great comments there. Regarding the name, it probably makes more sense around here given it was conceived for German speakers, I like the idea of the beneficiary and message; would definitely make it all more universal.

      Cheers

      Noel

  • Vitor Marcellino

    Vitor Marcellino

    Rank: 2 Titan

    2116

    • Design: 4
    • Purpose: 2
    • Originality: 4
    • Engagement: 2
    1 Vote
    This review has been awarded.
    Draft

    Posted on Nov 30, 2010 at 6:44 AM

    Hi Noel, nice design, I liked the layout in general.

    My opinion is that the educational part is good, maybe you could improve the donation.

    Here are some ideas for you:

    The donate button stands out, but I would like to see some more reasons to donate.

    Maybe adding a section like "How many people already donated" or something like that.

    Show people how easy is to donate, tell them what payment options they have.

    You could use the top left blank space to show how much the institution already have in donations.

    • Noel Tock
      Noel Tock commented:
      Posted: on Dec 02, 2010 at 1:14 PM

      Hi Vitor,

      Thank you for the comments, agree on the donation stuff (still waiting on comments there from the client though :/ )

      Cheers

      Noel

  • J V

    J V

    Rank: 2 Titan

    856

    • Design: 3
    • Purpose: 3
    • Originality: 2
    • Engagement: 2
    1 Vote
    This review has been awarded.
    News section could be more effective

    Posted on Dec 01, 2010 at 10:51 PM

    I am ok with this design from the header upto the girl image and the caption but the design failed to capture attention from there itself. The overview and News section appear to be heavy and burdenful for user.

    News section is very boring and not appealing. All news with a photograph, one heading and some content upto the bottom same design... looks very clumsy. Instead you can follow this format with image for just two news items in the top, and displaying the other news items as text links as show in www.ndtv.com Top stories section. One video news among this list would be interesting for current user population. Avoid "View all news" link since users are never interested to see the unknown news for which they dont have an idea.

    Overview section also is very pathetic with more text. Align the logos properly under sponsors.

    Otherwise I liked the girl image which is setting the emotional theme for users and the header part is just fine.

    Meet the Team can be brought up as part of overview by reducing some text from the current overview. I liked the Joel's placement of sponsors' logos and Donate button.

    • Noel Tock
      Noel Tock commented:
      Posted: on Dec 02, 2010 at 1:29 PM

      Thanks J,

      Honest comments and I appreciate it! Design has come a long way since thank god :)

      Cheers

      Noel

  • Anna Mikhailova

    Anna Mikhailova

    Rank: 3 Superior

    1141

    • Design: 2
    • Purpose: 3
    • Originality: 2
    • Engagement: 3
    1 Vote
    This review has been awarded.
    draft

    Posted on Nov 28, 2010 at 1:28 PM

    Hi, Noel

    I think it’s a good start. What bothers me in your design so far is the very tragic appeal. What they do is very serious matter, but they are actually working on hope and solution rather than mourning. I looked at the existing website, and aside being a mess, it has that pink flower image, that does just that: a feeling of hope. I am not suggesting using that image of course, but bringing some aliveness into design with imaging, some color, round corners and font, as was mentioned above. All your other websites are very much alive, and it seems to me that you having an issue with doing it in a magazine style and no texture. I personally always freeze, when someone says: I need it to be sleek and simple:))) But you can do it!

    Best of luck!

    • Noel Tock
      Noel Tock commented:
      Posted: on Dec 02, 2010 at 12:29 PM

      Hi Anna,

      Thank you very much for the comments, it helped out a lot and was the direction I needed to get this back on track (especially as I had pumped out 2 other PSD's that day and was crap tired)...

      Thanks again!

      Cheers

      Noel

  • Oksana

    Oksana

    Rank: 2 Titan

    426

    • Design: 3
    • Purpose: 3
    • Originality: 2
    • Engagement: 2
    1 Vote
    This review has been awarded.
    Sponsors

    Posted on Nov 27, 2010 at 6:50 PM

    Hi there!

    I really like idea of black and blue. But this blue is too bright for me, especially on the white background.

    "Sponsors" takes too much space, and logos are too big.

    Columns "Overview" and "News"are too close to each other.

    Picture of girl is awesome! I like it, it works very well for this kind of website.

    Good luck! :)

    • Noel Tock
      Noel Tock commented:
      Posted: on Dec 02, 2010 at 12:04 PM

      Hi Oksana,

      Thank you for the comments. Good comment re: sponsor size. Pic/Colors were just placeholders... already changed again :) Client just needs to provide the goods...

      Cheers

      Noel

    • Oksana
      Oksana commented:
      Posted: on Dec 02, 2010 at 12:11 PM

      Hope your client will like it. Happy I could help. :-)

  • Cedric Ruiz

    Cedric Ruiz

    Rank: 2 Titan

    1244

    • Design: 3
    • Purpose: 3
    • Originality: 2
    • Engagement: 2
    0 Votes
    Good colors

    Posted on Dec 13, 2010 at 9:52 PM

    That girl in the photo looks hypnotic rather than sick if thats what you going for. I like the colors. The footer needs some work and the sponsors I would position them in the footer. The mail icon is too bright and drags too much attention. I would get rid of the border in the photos of the right column.

  • Clayton Curtis

    Clayton Curtis

    Rank: 4 Master

    207

    • Design: 4
    • Purpose: 4
    • Originality: 2
    • Engagement: 3
    0 Votes
    Draft

    Posted on Dec 17, 2010 at 5:59 AM

    I can assume this is in WordPress. The homepage is just what it needs to be; clean and to the point. The picture of the girl almost reminds me of that famous National Geographic picture of the woman with the piercing eyes.

    Having a site like this in WordPress is great because you'll constantly be wanting to update readers on the latest in research in development.

  • Stefanescu Marian

    Stefanescu Marian

    Rank: 5 Advanced

    19

    • Design: 3
    • Purpose: 4
    • Originality: 3
    • Engagement: 3
    0 Votes
    The details

    Posted on Dec 17, 2010 at 1:02 PM

    Hello, I've saw the design and at the first look it's nice.But as a designer(webmaster) you should follow some rules to obtain a website that is atractive and modern in the same time.

    The first thing that poped in to my eyes was the free white space between elements.The white space is very important because it's separting the elements.Without it, the elements would look just like a block of content, that is usally hard to distinct.You should kepp maybe 30-35 px between OVERVIEW and NEWS.

    You should move up the logo and the menu.It's very important for the wesbite to look simetric(to look).I pointed "to look" because sometimes(yes it's true) it's only an optical illusion.

    The button Donate should be cleaner becuase the overall design of the website is clean.Remove the noise and add a gradient with some effects.Personally the button Donate looks from another website.You should improve it a little.I think that the Donate button must pop in the users's eyes but there are a lots of methods to achieve this.

    At the news section you've put a light grey (#ccc or something like that) as background.Again you should remove that.I think it could be much more elegant if you will use a jquery to change the bg when the user hover over the div(or what it is).Maybe from #fefefe to #f0f0f0(just an example).

    At the footer part:The link Read more about the team:the underline decoration looks to bold.You should use a jquery effect or a hover stuff.

    The tranzitions from the content to the footer it's too fast.You should first add a big nice border(5-8px) that has a darker grey than the background color from the content and only after that put the gradient.

    I hope that my advice helped you!Cheers...Marian