I like them all, but #2 is my favorite. I think you are using the right blend of iconic design and realism. #2 is much more versatile, you can easily create a black and white version if necessary. You may want to experiment with a comp that doesn't use the page fold.. page folds are a little overused in my opinion. The wine drops on #1 could be mistaken for blood splatter.. I've been watching too much Dexter lately.

I like #2, has the two keywords symbolised: wine and books. Just make the bottle a wee bit bigger to be more visible. The other two don't exactly show the purpose.

2 is more iconic and gives the opportunity for more and wider use than the other two options. Though I might consider putting the heart in the bottle silouhette.

Great stuff here. #2 all the way!

I would lose the page flip, like most are suggesting for #2. One more thing to consider – this logo is uniform, up and down. I would lose some of its predictability and angle the wine bottle a bit (similar to what you did to the words in #1, but in the opposite direction). This will give it a dynamic interest and keep it almost playful, but still professional.

Hope this helps.

Of the three designs i like number two the best, one and three have very little to do with wine IMO. Also not much that could be improved on design 2, nicely done :)

Number 2.

Have a look at the bottle for the second icon. At small sizes I would think its a cricket bat.

2 is the best but don't put the page curl on it. Maybe put make the bottle a deep brown instead of white.

Im not sure if the book (number 2) shoud have that page flip. It should be a cover, shouldnt? So it would be hard... aaaand the books corner is rounded. On the flip it is square! ;)

I like the number 1 with the spots on the top, but the spots on the bottom looks more realistic for wine. The second looks like blood! lol

great job, anyway!