9 Reviews1 Vote0 Favorites259 Views
Concept Reviews
-
I think that you could really use any of these. The third is my least favorite, white the 1st and 2nd are my favorite. The play button gets a little lost on the fourth one. Good work here...
-
Kevin Goldman Goldman commented:Thanks Nate for the input. Which do you feel will more effortlessly and quickly communicate "Learning" to users?
-
Nate Hamilton commented:The first one does the best job at communicating your message.
-
-
No. 3 seems best, as the text in the window feels like programming.
-
Since this is online 2 will most likely be the best. With that said though I really like the way 4 looks-it is more dimensional, but since this is online the book may be misleading.
3 has too much going on with the text and 1 is more of an old style and since the target is 18 to 40 year olds then more modern is better.
-
1 most accurately represents, "Learn", as it puts the user at the center of the metaphor.
2 is too generic / doesn't have clear meaning.
3 represents "code" well, but I don't see a clear representation of "Learn", and I think overall it's too detailed for an icon.
4 would be my second choice for "Learn", but I think the book opens it up to too many interpretations, and does not at all imply a video.
-
1 is probably the most literal and informative, but something about the guys head bothers me...it's so msft little people, and it feels dull.
I like #4 the most because it feels a little more fun and fresh, even though it's not literal. The motion of the lines give it a little spark that #1 lacks. If there will be text next to it explaining what's going on, then #4 is the best. If it's stand alone, then maybe rework #1 to have a little more motion/energy in it.
-
If used with text on the side I would go for: 1-emphasis on the screen which is essential in coding :) 4-emphasis on the book which means knowledge
Issues: - none of these icons would work without description on the right - I don't thing mouse is the coding 'device' - 'Play' can be easily missed, I've not seen it for quite a long time :)
How about 5th approach: only 'play' icon and '<code>' symbols
Good work
-
1) no. 4 (I am so old school :-D), 2) no.3 but maybe no. 2 is better as a icon, it is simpler.
-
Kevin Goldman Goldman commented:
Thanks Miro. Which icon 1-4 do you feel speaks to the concept of "Learning" the most?
-
Miro commented:I think no. 4 is the most "learning", book is always so obvious sign for learning (to me).
-
-
The mouse + browser combo really work well. #3 is a little busier, though. #1 is too general (to me, I would think it has to do with a contact page). #4 is also good - it really emphasizes the "learning" aspect.
I think any one of those three would do well.
-
Kevin Goldman Goldman commented:
Thanks Serina - of #3 or #4, which do you feel will more effortlessly and quick communicate "Learning" to users?
-
